14 August 2022

Should I stay or should I go?

There are around 11.8 million people who have built up benefits in private sector defined benefit pensions and its seems that higher transfer values are increasingly tempting people to leave these so called "gold-plated" schemes.

There has been a huge increase in interest in defined benefit (aka Final Salary) pension scheme transfer values since new pension freedoms legislation was introduced by Chancellor George Osbourne in 2015. According to the FCA, 34,053 people were provided with a recommendation to transfer or convert their defined benefit pension between April 2020 and September 2021 alone.¹.

The Financial Times previously reported “cash lump sums offered to individuals looking to give up generous final salary pensions have jumped to records highs.” According to the insurance company Royal London, six million people with defined benefit pensions have seen their transfer values increase significantly. The insurer suggests some members are being offered "eye-watering" sums, often tens of thousands of pounds more than several years ago. For an individual with a pension income worth £20,000, it is not uncommon to be offered 30 times that amount, in other words, £600,000 in cash.

A Royal London survey of more than 800 financial advisers found growth of more than 50% in the volume of transfers out of defined benefit pensions taking place in 2017, with the most common transfer value lying in the £250,000 - £500,000 range. The vast majority of clients transferring were in their 50s, and the typical cash sum offered is between 25 and 30 times the value of the annual pension given up.

So why are so many people transferring out of these schemes that offer a guaranteed payment for life? The answer is twofold: Transfer values for defined benefit schemes have been at inflated levels recently and secondly, the recently introduced pension freedoms that provide for vastly improved flexibility in how a pension can be taken applies to Defined Contribution (DC schemes) only.

Inflated transfer values

Transfer values are the sums paid from a pension scheme when a member chooses to withdraw their entitlement. In the past, lack of knowledge and lethargy meant many people kept pensions in previous employers’ schemes until they came to retirement.

The level of a transfer value from a defined benefit scheme is not specified in the scheme’s rules, unlike other benefits. The terms used are set by the trustees, on the advice of the scheme actuary, at the time of the transaction. Transfer values paid from defined benefit schemes are the only ones that require assumptions about the future. Also, due to the pooling of risk between members, the level of transfer payment can also affect other people’s entitlements. The scheme actuary’s aim is to calculate the “best estimate” of the amount needed to buy the equivalent to the scheme entitlement. The actuary has to tread a careful line to be fair to both sides, ensuring any transferring member and those remaining in the scheme are not left worse off. The actuary also has to be mindful that schemes have to guarantee their transfer value quotations for a period of at least three months to give members time to make arrangements with an insurer.

So let’s briefly look at the reasons for the increased transfer values in the last couple of years which has sparked increased interest from members.

Transfer value calculations require assumptions about discount rates, inflation rates and demographic assumptions, all of which apply many years into the future and so there is considerable uncertainty over how these factors will play out. Discount rates are often based on long-dated bonds adjusted for the scheme’s actual asset mix. Currently gilt yields are at low levels, which results in lower discount rates and higher transfer values. At the same time, the long-term inflation rate outlook has risen, which also tends to increase transfer values in many defined benefit schemes.

Experience suggests that those who have requested and received inflated transfer values may also have told their friends and families about the relative size of their transfer values, encouraging more people to consider transferring.

Cash lump sums offered to individuals looking to give up generous final salary pensions have jumped to records highs.

The Financial Times

Pension freedom

Members transfer for different reasons. They might feel more secure with a policy in their own name, in case anything happened to the scheme; the BHS pension debacle in 2018 is an example of this. Or perhaps they want to have all their pensions in one place. It also allows defined benefit members to tailor their pension to suit their own needs, where these differ from those in the scheme’s rules, for example by:

— Taking their pension earlier or later than the scheme rules offer

— Allowing for different levels of inflation protection

Altering the level of dependants’ pensions to provide more or less for a spouse, or to remove them completely if they have no dependants

Pension freedoms introduced in 2015 changed this in a big way, encouraging more members to transfer. Since 2015 holders of defined contribution plans:

— Do not have to buy an annuity

— Can draw their pension flexibly

— Can even take the whole pot as cash, although this would be subject to tax

The important point is that these freedoms only apply to members of defined contribution schemes, so if defined benefit scheme members wish to take advantage of the flexibilities, they must transfer. Publicity over the new legislation also seems to have spurred people into considering their own pension and taking action.

It must be noted however, that if a scheme is underfunded, paying out a full transfer value could mean remaining members are left worse off. Underfunded schemes, those with a poor outlook for returning to full funding, may reduce transfer values (an “actuarial reduction”) so as not to disadvantage those left behind even further.

Transfer incentives

Over the past few years, more defined benefit schemes have closed and sought to reduce the risk in their scheme. BP confirmed in early 2021 that it will close its defined benefit pension scheme to future accrual and retail giant British Airways told its active defined benefit members that they will no longer be able to accrue additional benefits.

One way to further reduce risk for the scheme trustees is to reduce the number of members and the size of the scheme’s liabilities, which means the members who transfer out are helping the de-risking process. This has led some schemes to offer incentives, by increasing transfer values, as an inducement to transfer away.

The typical cash sum offered is between 25 and 30 times the value of the annual pension given up.

Royal London

Should you stay?

While obtaining the cash value of a defined benefit pension may be beneficial for some people, there can be significant disadvantages. Keeping a defined benefit pension is sensible for many people, as they offer:

  • Certainty: such pensions pay an income for life
  • Inflation protection
  •  Risk-free income, which does not depend on the ups and downs of the stock market

It is a regulatory requirement that anyone seeking a transfer over £30,000 must seek advice from a suitably qualified financial planner and the trustees of the ceding defined benefit scheme must ascertain that this has been done. Otherwise, the transfer is not permitted.

We would encourage members of defined benefit schemes to seek advice to review their situation and their entitlement from the scheme, including the benefits at retirement and the relative transfer value offered. The advice process can often be complex and a member should consider carefully their options with their adviser. Giving up a guaranteed payment for life is a big decision so any action should not be taken without due consideration. Simon Wong FPFS Senior Wealth Planner, JM Finn The typical cash sum offered is between 25 and 30 times the value of the annual pension given up. Royal London

¹ The figures are according to https://www.fca.org.uk/freedom-information/data-defined-benefits-pension-transfer-activities-february-2022

Investment involves risk. The value of investments and the income from them can go down as well as up and investors may not get back the amount originally invested.

The information provided in this document is of a general nature. It is not a substitute for specific advice with regard to your own circumstances.

Any views expressed are those of the author. All figures were correct at the time of going to print. You are recommended to obtain professional advice before you take any action or refrain from action. You should contact the person at JM Finn with whom you usually deal if you wish to discuss any of the topics mentioned.

Click here for more articles from our Pension Report


Should I stay or should I go


Understanding Finance

Helping clients understand what we do is key to building relationships. To explain some of the industry jargon that creeps into our world, we’ve pulled together a section of our site to help.

Growing your wealth

Discretionary portfolio management